What happens after someone is let go and why our management playbooks aren’t enough.
A few years ago, Be the Change Consulting went through a series of painful personnel transitions. Layoffs, firings, departures. Some were necessary. Some were complicated. All of them left a mark.
As CEO, I was responsible for making or carrying out those decisions. And I was completely unprepared for how deeply they would affect me. I kept returning to the decisions, the conversations, the relationships, and the things I wished I’d done differently. Intellectually, I understood why certain decisions had been made. But my body seemed to be holding something my brain couldn’t quite resolve.
I went looking for help in the management literature. There was plenty of advice about documentation, performance improvement plans, legal compliance, communication strategies, and protecting organizational morale.
But almost nothing addressed the profound human impact of losing one’s place in an organization. Not necessarily because the decision was wrong. Sometimes it’s absolutely necessary. But work is rarely just transactional. It’s where we build friendships, identities, routines, purpose, and sometimes even family.
When those relationships are severed, the impact extends far beyond what we acknowledge. So I started talking to leaders who had let people go, employees who had been fired or laid off, colleagues who had watched friends leave under painful circumstances, and people who were relieved when a struggling coworker finally departed.
What struck me was that almost nobody was okay.
The invisible ecosystem of a personnel decision
Imagine mapping everyone affected by a single personnel transition. At the center is the employee leaving. They might feel devastated, angry, embarrassed, frightened, or even relieved.
[add read more here and direct to website]
Then there’s the manager, who may have spent months coaching, documenting, giving feedback, and hoping something would change. They might feel frustrated, guilty, relieved, or like they’ve failed someone they genuinely cared about.
There’s HR, balancing organizational protection with a fair process. Senior leadership, holding responsibilities and information others may never fully see. And then the circles expand.
There’s the colleague who was a close friend of the departing employee and feels betrayed by leadership. Another who experienced that person’s performance challenges firsthand and is quietly relieved. And someone who barely knew the person but is suddenly wondering: Could that happen to me?
Every personnel decision sends a message beyond the person directly affected. How an organization treats one person becomes evidence of how it might treat everyone else. The challenge is that each person is experiencing a different reality, often with only a fraction of the information.
The tiger and the deer
Have you ever watched a nature documentary where the camera follows a tiger hunting a deer? When the story centers the tiger, I’m rooting for it to catch its dinner. When the camera follows the deer, I’m desperate for it to escape.
The same event produces a completely different emotional experience. I think about this when listening to stories about difficult personnel transitions. I can feel the hurt and betrayal of someone who was fired. I can also understand the exhaustion and grief of a manager who spent a year trying to help that person succeed. And I can appreciate the anxiety, anger, or relief of the colleagues left behind.
The challenge isn’t deciding whose experience is legitimate. It’s developing the capacity to hold a 360-degree perspective when everyone involved is experiencing only part of the story. And this is where conventional approaches to managing transitions fall short.
Six tensions we need to learn to hold
Over time, I identified six tensions that emerge during organizational transitions:
- Compassion and accountability. How do we care for someone while still holding them to expectations?
- Grief and relief. How do we make room for loss when others may be celebrating a necessary change?
- Individual and collective needs. How do we honor the person leaving while attending to those who remain?
- Relationships and responsibility. How do we navigate personal loyalties alongside our obligations as leaders?
- Dignity and transparency. How do we protect someone’s privacy while giving others enough information to maintain trust?
- Continuity and transformation. How do we restore stability while acknowledging that something fundamental has changed?
These aren’t problems with tidy solutions. They require judgment, empathy, and the ability to hold multiple truths simultaneously. And understanding them intellectually is only part of the work.
When the framework came alive
A few weeks ago, I had the opportunity to experiment with this framework at the Schools Out Washington conference in Seattle, where I delivered a keynote and facilitated several workshops.
One was called Human-Centered Transitions.
I’d wanted to try something like this for years. Rather than simply teaching about personnel transitions, we invited participants to share stories of layoffs, firings, and departures they’d experienced. Artists from the Belonging Resident Company, our Playback Theater ensemble, listened to those stories and reflected them back through improvised theater, movement, and sound.
Big, complex feelings returned as art. We witnessed betrayal, hurt, misunderstanding, relief, emptiness, and the exhaustion of trying to do the right thing and still causing pain.
Playback brought the framework out of my head and into my body. Instead of analyzing competing needs from a distance, we experienced them. We could feel the humanity of people whose perspectives might otherwise seem incompatible.
Something shifted for me. Some of the feelings I’d been carrying from our own organizational transitions finally had somewhere to go.
Not because I suddenly had all the answers, but because I could experience the complexity without needing to resolve it. And I started wondering: How many of us are carrying these experiences years after the decisions have been made?
What would it mean to handle transitions differently?
We can’t eliminate the pain of every layoff, firing, or departure. Nor should we confuse human-centered leadership with the avoidance of difficult decisions.
But we can change how we approach them.
Here are five places to start:
- Map the full ecosystem of impact. Consider everyone affected, not just the departing employee. What might each person need to maintain dignity, trust, and stability?
- Make room for multiple truths. Resist establishing a single organizational narrative. People can have very different experiences of the same event, and all of those experiences can be acknowledged.
- Protect dignity without creating a vacuum. Confidentiality matters, but silence breeds speculation and fear. Leaders can explain processes, values, expectations, and what comes next without disclosing private information.
- Attend to the people who remain. The transition doesn’t end when someone leaves the building. Teams need opportunities to process what happened, ask questions, rebuild relationships, and regain trust.
- Recognize that leaders need processing spaces, too. Making a necessary decision doesn’t mean it was painless. Leaders need places to reflect, grieve, and learn without asking employees to carry that emotional burden.
Perhaps most importantly, we need to stop assuming that a well-managed administrative process is the same thing as a well-held human transition.
I’m still learning how to do this.
The framework I’ve developed has helped me make sense of experiences I couldn’t previously explain. But bringing it into a room with real people, real stories, and embodied practice opened something new. I’m increasingly convinced that some of the most important organizational development work isn’t simply helping people understand what happened.
It’s helping them process what happened, so they can move forward without carrying its unresolved weight into every new relationship, decision, and organizational change.
At Be the Change Consulting, we’re beginning to bring together our organizational development practice with the embodied storytelling and Playback Theater methods of the Belonging Resident Company.
We’re particularly interested in working with organizations that have experienced difficult transitions and are ready to rebuild trust, restore relationships, and make sense of what they’ve been through.
Because sometimes the decision is over, but the transition is still happening.
Has your organization experienced a difficult personnel transition that people are still carrying? We’re experimenting with new ways to help teams process organizational change through storytelling, embodied reflection, and facilitated dialogue. We’d love to explore what that could look like for your team.
Sangita Kumar
Mother. Cultural Strategist. Facilitator.


