From The Blog

Impact Over Intent: for White Folks Participating in Equity Trainings

During a recent Becoming an Antiracist Organization training, a white woman wrote something in the chat that derailed our training content for a moment. It impacted our training team of color and the participants in the room. Her quick, damaging side comment read: “I don’t agree with Robin Diangelo’s work on whiteness.”

Boom. Those of us who lead trainings in diversity, equity and inclusion are used to these kinds of comments and the need to mitigate the harm they cause. We knew the racial identity of “White, Ann” (whose name is changed for confidentiality) because in our sessions, we invite participants to add racial identities to their virtual nametags. This is an important way to challenge the myth of race neutrality. As a result, it’s not just “Ann” sharing a perspective in an equity training, it is Ann who identifies as white, sharing. That makes a big difference! What unfolded with her comment was that other white-identified people began agreeing with Ann in the chat and the People of Color in our Zoom room began pushing back.

It’s not surprising that white folks struggle with concepts in Robin Diangelo’s book, White Fragility. The internet (and perhaps other chat threads) are full of debate. But intellectual debate is not that interesting to me or the other trainers on my team. Here’s what is, and what I realize we need to acknowledge for our training participants.

We make an agreement in our equity trainings to focus on impact over intent.

It is inherently frustrating for me to see a white person challenging the concepts presented in “White Fragility” instead of taking in the concepts we present in antiracism training. As a woman of color, I felt sad and exhausted as I witnessed the exchange. Why don’t white people understand the harm this causes in a mixed-race group? If, like “White Ann,” you are unaware of how such a comment is problematic, let me break it down.

Interrupting a multi-racial learning space on antiracism with intellectual debate, centers white expertise and white comfort. Who knows what the intent was- maybe she felt offended, confused or stuck. But the impact is that a white person took up space with their fragility, discomfort and confusion. Then, they amplified their own fragility in a mixed race space, taking focus off the real learning- how white supremacy systematically harms all of us and what we need to do to dismantle it.

In a mixed race space, white folks get to step back and listen. I understand that you see your questions as urgent, but they can wait. Often, you are confident speaking up in large groups because you have practice being seen and being affirmed for what you say. White supremacy has taught you that your learning needs are more important than the needs of others. Now, you are unconscious of the ways that a question might feel academic to you but land as deeply personally wounding to someone with a different identity. This is the harm your intellectual debate causes. There is a better way!

Triggered on Your Antiracism Journey, White Folks? Try this.

1. Be Humble. Instead of projecting your expertise with an opinion, the antiracist pivot is to approach with humility. Say: “I would love to hear from folks who learned something from this book. “hat did you learn? How are you applying it?”

2. Talk to Other White People. Instead of bringing up your learning needs in a mixed race group, talk to other white folks. Find three white-identified people who think differently than you and pose a neutral question.

Don’t say things like “I totally disagreed with x. What do you think?” Or “this made no sense to me. Can you break it down for me?” These loaded questions will automatically put you into the defensive mode. Your white friends will move into politeness and won’t challenge your thinking. You will walk away feeling confirmed in your beliefs and miss a chance to learn and grow.

3. Shift into a Growth Mindset. Try saying: “I feel like I’m missing an opportunity to broaden my mind in this work. I would love help to see it from a different perspective.” Really listen with curiosity and expect to grow and change.

We Center the Expertise of People of Color

I want to acknowledge the labor our participants of color do in every session that we hold. There is always the risk in multi-racial spaces that whiteness will flare up and cause harm. As we hold space for productive dialogue, we see new ways to structure the conversation to center the expertise of Black-identified people, Indigenous folk and People of Color. We’ll continue to notice and dismantle ways that we’re distracted from the tough work of creating transformational organizational practices.

Deep bows to all of us on this journey. Let us persist, stumble and persist some more.

Together we will arrive.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Aliquam in tristique dolor, in euismod nisi. Phasellus luctus sit amet odio in dapibus. Donec et metus velit. Maecenas imperdiet felis sed mi hendrerit posuere. Nam eu gravida arcu. Sed velit libero, faucibus a est lobortis, pulvinar volutpat ex. Donec et metus velit. Maecenas imperdiet felis sed mi hendrerit posuere. Nam eu gravida arcu. Sed velit libero, faucibus a est lobortis, pulvinar volutpat ex.

Explore

Our Team

About Us Read About Us
Did you enjoy this article? share on:
more from the blog
Becoming Antiracist Through Website Redesign
Becoming Antiracist Through Website Redesign

Don’t think we missed the opportunity to dismantle dominant culture traits that flared up in the process of creating a new website. Right to comfort as we chose fonts and images? Yep. Worship of the written word in the editing process? Definitely. Find out what we noticed and how we pivoted and claimed antidotes to white supremacy culture.

read more
Feedback Fragility
Feedback Fragility

Research-backed training in diversity, inclusion, leadership, and antiracism complete with experiential learning opportunities.

read more
LO

Lisette Ostrander

Director of Education at Beyond Differences

SW

Sarah Wan

Executive Director at CYC

PP

Priscilla Parchia

Program Manager, Expanded Learning

AM

Ay'Anna Moody

Director, Social Impact & Generation Thrive

RL

Rodd Lee

Assistant General Manager, External Affairs

EG

Erin Gutiérrez

Director of Learning & Development

AB

Ariana Bayer

Manager of Family Programs

PC

Pam Connie

JN

Jill Nielsen

FC

Felix Caraballo

PMB

P. Marcia Brown

DG

Deanna Grant-Curtis

A

Anonymous

A

Anonymous

A

Anonymous

A

Anonymous

A

Anonymous

A

Anonymous

A

Anonymous

A

Anonymous

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

I am the Director of Education for Beyond Differences. I worked with Fong in the late summer/ fall of 2020. Fong coached me as I prepared to launch an educator cohort series in NYC and FL for close to 70 educators. My primary goals were to build an intentional learning community, support Read More

LO

Lisette Ostrander

Director of Education at Beyond Differences

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

When developing capacity for my team of 100+ staff, Be the Change Consulting is our go-to organization. Whether I need guidance for our newly hired direct service staff or non-profit veterans from our leadership team, I trust in BTCC to offer the groundwork to address all our needs. They Read More

SW

Sarah Wan

Executive Director at CYC

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

We have been using the Building Intentional Communities Curriculum for a decade now and continue to come back for more curriculum, more PD, and support. We have continued, renewed, and recommended BTCC’s services because they are exactly what our communities need. Thoughtful, communal, Read More

PP

Priscilla Parchia

Program Manager, Expanded Learning

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

This year we were excited to partner with Be the Change Consulting, Hellman Foundation and the Walter & Elise Haas Senior Fund to launch a virtual training series just as the pandemic hit and the shelter in place order was announced. We wanted to offer relevant and responsive training and Read More

AM

Ay'Anna Moody

Director, Social Impact & Generation Thrive

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Dynamic…diverse…engaging…extraordinary…innovative…inclusive. Those are just a few terms that describe Be the Change Consulting.

Their team of highly skilled professionals, exceptionally led by Sangita Kumar, assisted BART with extensive outreach and in-depth engagement with Read More

RL

Rodd Lee

Assistant General Manager, External Affairs

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Be the Change Consulting has been a key partner over the years providing training and support that tends to both content expertise and humanizing processes. The workshops are engaging, thought-provoking, and grounded in the latest academic research, and I most appreciate that their facilitators Read More

EG

Erin Gutiérrez

Director of Learning & Development

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Participating in Be The Change Consulting’s Antiracism capacity building series has supported tremendous growth for me professionally through the development of an anti-racist perspective and actions, from big picture project goals and assessments all the way down to how our team opens Read More

AB

Ariana Bayer

Manager of Family Programs

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Excellent and I attend a LOT of these training sessions. Well organized. Clear and courageous content.

PC

Pam Connie

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

I really appreciated the hands on skills at the end of the session.
Very engaging and extremely informed – presented material in an accessible and interesting manner.

I would recommend at least 3 hours for this training.

JN

Jill Nielsen

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

It’s a different facilitation style that you have but I can see how it works. It’s a much more human experience, rather than a student teacher discussion. I’m impressed.

Great Job.

FC

Felix Caraballo

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Thank you for demonstrating your passion: Be The Change; was evident. I appreciate the copy of the PP.

PMB

P. Marcia Brown

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

I love this organization. Their curriculum is some of the best I’ve ever used! Tried and true.

DG

Deanna Grant-Curtis

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Appreciate y’all Aminta & Thomas! I wish we could combine our collective superpowers in facilitating.

A

Anonymous

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

It was really helpful to have to say the actual words. Because it highlighted an issue that could have easily been glossed over- Thank you group.

A

Anonymous

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Thank you all for an amazing learning experience.

A

Anonymous

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Thank you so much. These strategies are really helpful and actionable!!

A

Anonymous

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Thank you for this extremely enriching experience!

A

Anonymous

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Thank you for a great session. This has been really informative and helpful.

A

Anonymous

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Thanks y’all. I am leading a capacity building cohort of 49 orgs. I am definitely going to share your info with them and explore with the foundation partners funding options for this work. Thank you!!!!! Love all of it 🙂

A

Anonymous

What Folx SayWhat folx (people of all genders) say about our work:

Facilitating techniques are great. They are great!

A

Anonymous

Subscribe For Free

Get the Be the Change Newsletter

Let’s Connect

Are you ready to be the change?

Menu

2744 E 11th St, Suite A1
Oakland, CA 94601
510.985.4152

Other Checkout Options